Mindfulness and fighting wild fires, and the value of simulations for training

Professor Karl Weick at the University of Michigan has written extensively on the need for "mindfulness" in emergency situations, such as, literally, fighting forest fires.

A mindful crew or crew-chief will be aware that they are operating on a mental model, and that model may be incorrect, so they must be alert to even very small signs that they have completely misconstrued the situation.

There are lessons here, on a longer time scale, for every leader, civilian or military.

Here are some public documents on the subject.

http://www.wy.blm.gov/fireuse/2009mtg/presentations/HROs-mindfulness.ppt

Teaching Mindfulness to Wildland Firefighters (Fire Management Today, Spring 2008, Dave Thomas)

For the last 3 years I have taught half-day workshops, conducted 1-hour lectures, and provided general awareness speeches about the Weick/ Sutcliffe model of High Reliability Organizing as described in their book Managing the Unexpected: Assuring High Performance in an Age of Complexity.

This article is a series of musings, conjectures, and recommendations pulled from this teaching experience. My intent is to pass on some of the lessons that I have learned teaching High Reliability Organizing, and to pose recommendations for further study...

Today, however, mainly due to the heating of the Earth through global warming and a build up of fuels -firefighters are working within an environmental framework of weather and fuel never experienced before. Errors that we might have "got away with" in the past could more easily become catastrophic today....

Next, I explain the irrationality (mindlessness) of always learning our primary safety lessons through trial and error. It is our job to be better at anticipating errors before they occur, before a brutal audit forces us to notice the discrepant events in the fire environment. The following quotation, which reinforces this view, is taken from French disaster expert Pat Lagadec:

"The ability to deal with a crisis situation is largely dependent on structures that have been developed before chaos arrives. The event can ... be considered an abrupt brutal audit: at a moment's notice, everything that was left unprepared becomes a complex problem, and every weakness comes rushing to the forefront."...

High Reliability Organizing

NEW! France-USA High Reliability Organizing in Incident Management Teams Project
Just like NYPD detective "Popeye" Doyle, who traveled to Marseilles in the 1970s hit movie “the French Connection” so too, did a Forest Service NIMO team this past December. Only it wasn’t for crime busting this time. It was a landmark match-up between two French and American Incident Management Teams to capture what makes these teams so successful in complex, rapidly changing, stressful situations. It is hypothesized that they exhibit many of the behaviors that directly align with high reliability organizing (HRO) concepts and principles.

( More to come)


More information:

The France-USA HRO Project (French Web Site, from Bouches du Rhone with video)
http://hro-fires.com/exercices_live.html

High-Reliability Organizing - Roberts, with Weick and Sutcliff:
http://www.wildfirelessons.net/HRO.aspx

Center for Catastrophic Risk Management, Berkely CA
http://ccrm.berkeley.edu

Communication and Information technologies:
New tools for DISASTER management
Jean-Michel DUMAZ (1)
Bouches-du-Rhône Fire Department – MARSEILLE - FRANCE
2nd International Conference on Urban Disaster Reduction
November 27~29, 2007

The Bouches du Rhône
Fire Department


Wade